Is Opting for a Voluntary Deductible Worth It? Pros and Cons Explained

Posted on: Dec 15, 2025 | 3 mins | Written by: HDFC ERGO Team

Is Opting for a Voluntary Deductible Worth It? Pros and Cons Explained

Voluntary Deductible: Worth Adding to Your Car Insurance

Opting for a voluntary deductible in car insurance can be valuable for low-risk individuals seeking upfront savings on policy premiums. However, this particular strategy may not be suitable for all car owners, especially those who are more likely to experience accidents. As the final decision rests on your shoulders, it is essential that you weigh the key advantages and disadvantages of a voluntary deductible beforehand.

In this blog, we will highlight the various pros and cons of a voluntary deductible in car insurance.

Why Consider a Voluntary Deductible in Car Insurance?

Unlike a compulsory deductible, a voluntary deductible is not a mandatory part of a car insurance policy. It is optional, and choosing it enables upfront savings on premiums as the policyholder agrees to a higher financial responsibility during claims. This is the main reason why individuals consider adding a voluntary deductible to their car insurance policy.

However, not everyone has the same risk tolerance or financial strength. So, the decision to choose a voluntary deductible in car insurance should only be made after careful consideration of the key aspects, such as risk appetite, financial stability and driving habits.

Pros and Cons of a Voluntary Deductible in Car Insurance

A voluntary deductible in car insurance has its own set of merits and demerits. The following list highlights some of the key ones:

Factors	Pros	Cons
Premium and savings	It can significantly lower the annual premium of your car insurance policy, reducing upfront costs and ensuring long-term savings.	In case of frequent insurance claims, the additional cost of a voluntary deductible on top of the compulsory deductible can outweigh these savings.
Financial responsibility during claims	Choosing a voluntary deductible motivates you to stay financially prepared to handle minor repairs out of pocket.	If you are not prepared to handle minor repairs on your own or the voluntary deductible during claims, it can become a financial burden.
Impact on driving behaviour and claims	Knowing you have to cover the voluntary deductible during settlements makes you more inclined to adopt safer driving habits and avoid filing for minor claims.	If you want to protect your NCB or avoid paying the voluntary deductible, you may skip filing for minor claims. This means you will have to pay for the minor repairs on your own, which may feel like it defeats the purpose of having car insurance.
Flexibility and coverage	Having the choice of adding a voluntary deductible to your car insurance policy gives you more options to customise your plan.	While it gives flexibility during policy purchase/renewal, failing to pay the voluntary deductible during claims can mean the insurer will not settle the claim.

When to Consider a Voluntary Deductible in Car Insurance?

Here’s when you should consider a voluntary deductible with your car insurance policy:

1. If you rarely use your car or live in a low-risk area.

2. If you are an experienced driver with a clean record and don’t make frequent claims.

3. If you want to make upfront savings on your car insurance premium.

4. If you only use car insurance for major claims.

5. If you are financially stable enough to comfortably handle the selected voluntary deductible at the time of claim.

When to Avoid a Voluntary Deductible in Car Insurance?

Here’s when you should avoid choosing a voluntary deductible with your car insurance:

1. If you use your car frequently or live in a high-risk zone.

2. If you are a new driver and are more prone to accidents.

3. If you depend on the maximum coverage from the insurer during claim settlements.

4. If you are not financially comfortable handling minor repairs or paying the voluntary deductible at the time of claim.

5. If the repairs for your vehicle are expensive, and the upfront savings on premiums are not worth paying higher deductibles.

Key Facts About Voluntary Deductible in Car Insurance

As you can see, having a clear idea about deductibles in car insurance is very critical. You can check out our blog on Understanding Deductibles in Comprehensive Car Insurance for more details

Also, before you proceed with your decision of whether to choose a voluntary deductible with your car insurance policy, here are some basic facts you must understand:

1. A voluntary deductible is not paid as part of the policy premium. When you make a car insurance claim, and it gets approved by the insurer, only then do you need to pay it.

2. Choosing a voluntary deductible does not eliminate the compulsory deductible. In this case, you need to cover the sum of both as out-of-pocket expenses during claims.

3. A voluntary deductible is not offered with third party car insurance. It is only available with standalone OD and comprehensive car insurance plans.

4. The discount offered by insurers upon choosing a voluntary deductible is only applicable to the own damage premium component of the car insurance policy.

Conclusion:

The voluntary deductible can be a convenient option for low-risk individuals looking to save money on car insurance policy premiums. It has its merits and demerits and should be chosen only after careful consideration of one’s risk appetite, driving habits and financial standing. If you can comfortably handle the higher deductible, it can save you money, both upfront and in the long term.

Disclaimer: The above information is for illustrative purposes only. For more details, please refer to policy wordings and prospectus before concluding the sales.

5 Reasons Why Comprehensive Car Insurance Costs More Than Third Party Liability Policy

Third Party Insurance Premium for Unlimited Liability

Know your rights as a third party in case of motor accidents

Rise of Third Party Motor Insurance Premium and Its Impact

Reasons Why Third Party Car Insurance Is Not Enough